recped wrote:
House wrap, Typar or Tyvek, I recommend the Typar as it is nowhere near as slippery as Tyvek.
I have some Tyvek left from construction projects, and used some to make a DIY footprint with scalloped edges., and pole/stake out grommets at the corners and center pole hoop.
The Tyvek version footprint left something to be desired if the ground was already went when setting up the tent, moisture too easily compressed through onto the tent floor.
So I tried a little experiment at home; a scrap of Tyvek held concave in a solo cup, depression filled with water. It took an hour, but all of the water eventually leaked through into the cup.
P6160904 by
Mike McCrea, on Flickr
Perhaps there are different Tyveks, or Typar is different, but as a footprint/groundcloth moisture barrier, especially when compressed on damp ground under sleeping pad & body pressure, it wasn’t a great wet ground solution. If it wasn’t so rustling noisy maybe used as an innie layer?
If I am making cheap and dirty custom tent footprints, with scalloped edges and pole-stake feet, a piece of 4ml plastic sheeting, colloquially “Visqueen”, is 100% waterproof when laid atop wet ground.
Custom visqueen footprint for a 4-person Alpine Meadow;, still a great 2-door, two vestibule (spacious) tent for two.
P6220935 by
Mike McCrea, on Flickr
DIY shaped for scalloped edge cutting by setting up the tent atop the visqueen, Sharpie the scalloped edges slightly under the tent body, and note where the pole end grommets were spaced.
P6220936 by
Mike McCrea, on Flickr
Scissors, tape, grommet kit, done. Couple of bucks.
On the downside plastic sheeting is also 100% impermeable for water puddled under the tent floor if any part of the ground cloth sticks out past the tent floor edges, so footprints made a little undersized for the tent body, with scalloped edges for sideways blowing rain, and pole/stake attachments made from Gorilla tape and grommets.
Pole/stake out corner grommets on a footprint are the best tent set up thing since shock corded poles. Lay the footprint out and stake down the four corners. Step back and ponder how that orientation looks, with a wind & weather eye, checking for angle, slope and anything WTF poking up. When it is windy out having the footprint staked down in chosen orientation and not blowing askew as you dash about is an efficiency assist.
DIY footprints are cheap enough to make, and if the 4ml visqueen gets holed after a few years I have the worn out version as a plastic cutting template.
Same with other tent footprints made on the cheap; we have two Hubba Hubbas, one bought with a perfectly designed but pricey MSR footprint, complete with scalloped edge & pole/stake corner loops.
IIRC the MRS footprint was, years ago, close to $50. Fifty bucks for a simple enough piece of ripstop PU coated nylon with four grommeted webbing pole feet/tieouts. They enticed me to buy the first one, and I liked it, but I wasn’t buying another, even if they were available. MRS now offers a “Universal Tent Footprint”; universal usually means compromises need to be made. No thanks.
I had some visqueen and tape and grommets in the shop, and the MSR footprint was perfectly designed for that tent, so I had a ready-made shape and features to copy.
I may have no sewing abilities, but I’ll never buy a pricey tent footprint again. At $50-$60 bucks I can make a dozen from plastic sheeting, tape and grommets, each customized for specific tent floors and poles.